regex - 使用 cl-ppcre 的正则表达式匹配错误？

Question

尝试解析以下文本文件:

prefix1 prefix2 name1(
                 type1 name1,
                 type2 name2
                 );

使用以下正则表达式:\\s*prefix1\\s*prefix2\\s*(\\w[\\w\\d_]*).*\\(\\s*([^\\)]*\\))\\s*;\\s*结果我得到以下两组(寄存器):

"name1(
             "

和

"(
             type1 name1,
             type2 name2
             )"

(这里引号限制了字符串，包括\n)

我不明白为什么第一组(\w[\w\d_]*)匹配以下 .*部分。
而且，我无法摆脱不必要的尾部!

我的错误是什么？

地址:解析的正则表达式:

(cl-ppcre::parse-string "\\s*prefix1\\s*prefix2\\s*(\\w[\\w\\d_]*).*\\(\\s*([^\\)]*\\))\\s*;\\s*")
(:SEQUENCE (:GREEDY-REPETITION 0 NIL :WHITESPACE-CHAR-CLASS) "prefix1"
 (:GREEDY-REPETITION 0 NIL :WHITESPACE-CHAR-CLASS) "prefix2"
 (:GREEDY-REPETITION 0 NIL :WHITESPACE-CHAR-CLASS)
 (:REGISTER
  (:SEQUENCE :WORD-CHAR-CLASS
   (:GREEDY-REPETITION 0 NIL (:CHAR-CLASS :WORD-CHAR-CLASS :DIGIT-CLASS #\_))))
 (:GREEDY-REPETITION 0 NIL :EVERYTHING) #\(
 (:GREEDY-REPETITION 0 NIL :WHITESPACE-CHAR-CLASS)
 (:REGISTER
  (:SEQUENCE (:GREEDY-REPETITION 0 NIL (:INVERTED-CHAR-CLASS #\))) #\)))
 (:GREEDY-REPETITION 0 NIL :WHITESPACE-CHAR-CLASS) #\;
 (:GREEDY-REPETITION 0 NIL :WHITESPACE-CHAR-CLASS))

添加 2:
完整的来源:

;; Requirements:
;; cl-ppcre

(defparameter *name-and-parameters-list* (cl-ppcre::create-scanner "\\s*prefix1\\s*prefix2\\s*(\\w[\\w\\d_]*)\\s*\\(\\s*([^\\)]*\\))\\s*;\\s*"))
(defparameter *filename* "c:/pva/home/test.txt")

(defun read-txt-without-comments (file-name)
  "Would epically fail in case the file format changes, because currently it expects
 the \"/*\" and \"*/\" sequences to be on the separate line."
  (let ((fstr (make-array '(0) :element-type 'base-char :fill-pointer 0 :adjustable t)))
    (with-output-to-string (s fstr)
      (let ((comment nil))
    (with-open-file (input-stream file-name :direction :input)
      (do ((line (read-line input-stream nil 'eof) (read-line input-stream nil 'eof)))
          ((eql line 'eof))
        (multiple-value-bind (start-comment-from)
        (cl-ppcre:scan ".*/\\*" line)
          (multiple-value-bind (end-comment-from)
          (cl-ppcre:scan ".*\\*/" line)
        (if start-comment-from
            (setf comment t))
        (if (not comment)
            (format s "~A~%" line))
        (if end-comment-from
            (setf comment nil))))))))
    fstr))

(let* ((string (read-txt-without-comments "c:/pva/home/test.txt")))
  (multiple-value-bind (a b c d) (cl-ppcre::scan *name-and-parameters-list* string)
    (format t "~a ~a ~a ~a~%|~a|~%|~a|~%"
        a b c d
        (subseq string (svref c 0) (svref c 1))
        (subseq string (svref d 0) (svref d 1)))))

添加 3: 完整的输入:

prefix1 prefix2 name1(
                 type1 name1,
                 type2 name2
                 );
prefix1 prefix2 name2(  type3 name1, type2 name2  );

Answer 1

这适用于我最近的 cl-ppcre正如您所期望的那样:

(cl-ppcre:register-groups-bind (name argument)
             ("\\s*prefix1\\s*prefix2\\s*(\\w[\\w\\d_]*).*\\(\\s*([^\\)]*\\))\\s*;\\s*"
              "prefix1 prefix2 name1(
                 type1 name1,
                 type2 name2
                 );" :sharedp t)
           (list name argument))
("name1" "type1 name1,
                 type2 name2
                 )")

也许，显示更多的代码？